Ingredients

For the crust:

Butter – 100 grams (0.5 cup)
Flour – 170 grams (1.5 cups)
Egg yolk – 1
Baking powder – 0.5 teaspoon
Salt – a pinch
Cold water – 2-3 tablespoons
We recommend:
For unsalted butter 100 grams:
Prime Artisana Organics Raw Almond Butter, 8 lbs | No Sugar Added, Bulk Unroasted Almond Butter, No Palm Oil, Vegan, Paleo, Keto Friendly and Non GMO
4.4
(2,620) Artisana Organics Raw Almond Butter, 8 lbs | No Sugar Added, Bulk Unroasted Almond Butter, No Palm Oil, Vegan, Paleo, Keto Friendly and Non GMO $109.98 View details Prime Anthony's Premium Butter Powder, 1 lb, Gluten Free, Non GMO, Made in USA, Keto Friendly, Hormone Free
4.6
(3,159) Anthony's Premium Butter Powder, 1 lb, Gluten Free, Non GMO, Made in USA, Keto Friendly, Hormone Free $18.49 View details
For all-purpose flour 170 grams:
Prime Antimo Caputo Chefs Flour - Italian Double Zero 00 - Soft Wheat for Pizza Dough, Bread, & Pasta, 2.2 Lb (Pack of 2)
4.7
(15,802) Antimo Caputo Chefs Flour - Italian Double Zero 00 - Soft Wheat for Pizza Dough, Bread, & Pasta, 2.2 Lb (Pack of 2) $16.99 View details Prime best seller King Arthur, Measure for Measure Flour, Certified Gluten-Free, Non-GMO Project Verified, Certified Kosher, 3 Pounds, Packaging May Vary
4.7
(20,691) King Arthur, Measure for Measure Flour, Certified Gluten-Free, Non-GMO Project Verified, Certified Kosher, 3 Pounds, Packaging May Vary $8.62 View details Prime Unpretentious All Purpose Flour, 5 Gallon Bucket, Versatile Kitchen Staple, Food Storage
4.7
(55) Unpretentious All Purpose Flour, 5 Gallon Bucket, Versatile Kitchen Staple, Food Storage $74.99 View details
For baking powder:
Prime Clabber Girl Double Acting Baking Powder, 8.1 Ounce
4.8
(10,144) Clabber Girl Double Acting Baking Powder, 8.1 Ounce $2.63 View details Prime 365 by Whole Foods Market, Baking Soda, 16 Ounce
4.7
(10,727) 365 by Whole Foods Market, Baking Soda, 16 Ounce $1.79 View details Prime best seller 365 by Whole Foods Market, Baking Powder Aluminum Free, 10 Ounce
4.8
(8,361) 365 by Whole Foods Market, Baking Powder Aluminum Free, 10 Ounce $3.29 View details

For the filling:

Toffees – 100 grams (3.5 ounces)
Egg yolks – 2
Milk – 150 milliliters (0.5 cup)
Cream cheese – 140 grams (5 ounces)
Heavy cream (33%) – 200 milliliters (0.75 cup)
Cornstarch – 2 tablespoons
Cinnamon – 1 teaspoon
We recommend:
For toffees 100 grams:
Prime Walkers' Nonsuch Assorted Toffees & Chocolate Eclairs | Contains English Creamy, Milk & Dark Chocolate Covered, Banana Split & Milk Toffees | Traditional British Candy | 44.09 Oz (1.25kg)
4.3
(4,165) Walkers' Nonsuch Assorted Toffees & Chocolate Eclairs | Contains English Creamy, Milk & Dark Chocolate Covered, Banana Split & Milk Toffees | Traditional British Candy | 44.09 Oz (1.25kg) $29.67 View details Prime Trader Joes English Toffee With Nuts,30 oz
4.3
(663) Trader Joes English Toffee With Nuts,30 oz $46.99 View details Prime Walkers' Nonsuch English Creamy Toffees | with Whole Milk & Butter | Imported from UK | Traditional British Sweets | Classic English Toffee | 88.18 Oz (2.5kg)
4.3
(526) Walkers' Nonsuch English Creamy Toffees | with Whole Milk & Butter | Imported from UK | Traditional British Sweets | Classic English Toffee | 88.18 Oz (2.5kg) $41.99 View details
For whole milk 150 milliliters:
Prime Prairie Farms Whole Milk - Shelf Stable, Boxed UHT Ultra Pasteurized Milk, Vitamin D White Milk - Preservative and Hormone Free - 1 Quart (12 Pack)
5
(7) Prairie Farms Whole Milk - Shelf Stable, Boxed UHT Ultra Pasteurized Milk, Vitamin D White Milk - Preservative and Hormone Free - 1 Quart (12 Pack) $80.99 View details Prairie Farms - Shelf Stable Milk 2% Percent, Reduced Fat, Boxed UHT Ultra Pasteurized Milk, Vitamin D White Milk - Preservative and Hormone Free, Gluten Free, Kosher, Made in USA (1 Quart - 4 Pack)
5
(4) Prairie Farms - Shelf Stable Milk 2% Percent, Reduced Fat, Boxed UHT Ultra Pasteurized Milk, Vitamin D White Milk - Preservative and Hormone Free, Gluten Free, Kosher, Made in USA (1 Quart - 4 Pack) $29.99 View details Horizon Organic Shelf-Stable Whole Milk boxes, Horizon Whole Milk Single Serve, 6pk/8.0 Fl oz
5
(1) Horizon Organic Shelf-Stable Whole Milk boxes, Horizon Whole Milk Single Serve, 6pk/8.0 Fl oz $22.86 View details
For cream cheese 140 grams:
Prime Judee’s Cream Cheese Powder 5 lb - 100% Non-GMO, Keto-Friendly - rBST Hormone-Free, Gluten-Free and Nut-Free - Made from Real Cream Cheese - Made in USA - Use in Spreads, Dips, and Baking
4.5
(232) Judee’s Cream Cheese Powder 5 lb - 100% Non-GMO, Keto-Friendly - rBST Hormone-Free, Gluten-Free and Nut-Free - Made from Real Cream Cheese - Made in USA - Use in Spreads, Dips, and Baking $68.99 View details Prime Rich's JW Allen Real Icing, Cream Cheese, 288 Ounce
4.3
(103) Rich's JW Allen Real Icing, Cream Cheese, 288 Ounce $75.85 View details Prime Kraft Philadelphia Lite Cream Cheese Cups (100 Pack)
4.1
(23) Kraft Philadelphia Lite Cream Cheese Cups (100 Pack) $86.22 View details
For heavy cream 33% 200 milliliters:
Prime Dr. Oetker Whipped Cream Stabilizer, 0.35 Ounce (Pack of 2)
4.3
(1,428) Dr. Oetker Whipped Cream Stabilizer, 0.35 Ounce (Pack of 2) $3.30 View details Double Devon Cream (6 ounce)
3.9
(786) Double Devon Cream (6 ounce) $14.99 View details Devon Cream Company Clotted Cream, 6 oz
3.4
(2,782) Devon Cream Company Clotted Cream, 6 oz $9.99 View details
For cornstarch:
Prime Corn Starch By Unpretentious Baker, Resealable 5-Gallon Bucket, Thickening Agent, For Bulk Baking & Cleaning Use (400 Ounces)
4.8
(7) Corn Starch By Unpretentious Baker, Resealable 5-Gallon Bucket, Thickening Agent, For Bulk Baking & Cleaning Use (400 Ounces) $109.99 View details Prime Earthborn Elements Corn Starch 2 Gallon Bucket, Thickening Agent, Cooking & Baking Staple, Cleaning
5
(12) Earthborn Elements Corn Starch 2 Gallon Bucket, Thickening Agent, Cooking & Baking Staple, Cleaning $43.99 View details Prime Clabber Girl, Corn Starch, 3.5lb
4.8
(2,949) Clabber Girl, Corn Starch, 3.5lb $19.90 View details
For ground cinnamon:
Prime FGO Organic Ceylon Cinnamon Powder, 100% Raw from Sri Lanka, 16oz, Packaging May Vary (Pack of 1)
4.6
(9,600) FGO Organic Ceylon Cinnamon Powder, 100% Raw from Sri Lanka, 16oz, Packaging May Vary (Pack of 1) $19.99 View details Prime Unpretentious Ground Cassia Cinnamon, 1 Gallon, Baking & Cooking
4.9
(13) Unpretentious Ground Cassia Cinnamon, 1 Gallon, Baking & Cooking $45.99 View details Prime Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Cinnamon, Ground, 15 ounce (Pack of 1)
4.8
(9,766) Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Cinnamon, Ground, 15 ounce (Pack of 1) $9.02 $10.31 View details

Instructions

Step 1

For the crust:

Sift the flour and mix with baking powder. Rub cold butter into the flour until it forms crumbs. Add salt and egg yolk, start kneading the dough, then add 2 tablespoons of cold water. Knead for about 5 minutes until the dough is smooth and non-sticky, yet easy to tear. Shape it into a ball, wrap in plastic wrap, and refrigerate for an hour.
After an hour, roll out the dough and place it in a pie tin. Prick the dough with a fork, cover with parchment paper, and fill with any grain (like rice) to prevent it from rising in the oven. Bake for 15 minutes at 180°C (350°F), then remove parchment and rice and bake for another 10 minutes.

Step 2

For the filling:

Chop the toffees finely, place them in a saucepan, add half of the milk (75 milliliters), and cook over low heat, stirring constantly until the toffees are completely melted. Remove from heat.
In a separate bowl, mix cornstarch with the remaining milk. Then mix this mixture with the egg yolks and add cinnamon.
In a third bowl, whip the heavy cream and cream cheese until peaks form. Gently mix the melted toffees with the egg mixture and carefully fold it into the whipped cream mixture using circular motions to keep the cream fluffy.
Pour the filling into the crust and bake for another 35-45 minutes. The filling will be liquid when you take it out, that’s normal. Let the pie cool completely.
After a few hours, you can decorate it with whipped cream and cinnamon.

Servings

Serving this Caramel Cream Pastry is half the fun! Picture this: a cozy afternoon tea gathering with friends or a relaxed family dinner where the dessert steals the show.

🍓 Top with Fresh Berries: For a burst of color and freshness, sprinkle a handful of raspberries or sliced strawberries on top. The contrast of tart berries and sweet caramel is divine.

🍨 Pair with Ice Cream: A scoop of vanilla or cinnamon ice cream makes a delightful companion to this creamy pastry. The ice cream’s cold creaminess against the warm pie—pure indulgence.

☕ Serve with Coffee: The rich flavors of caramel perfectly complement a hot cup of coffee. Try a latte or even a spiced chai for a cozy twist.

Have fun with your presentation! 🥳 Use a dusting of cocoa powder or cinnamon and a sprig of mint for a touch of elegance. Remember, the first bite is with the eyes! 🌟

Equipment

Mixing Bowls

Ensure you have at least three mixing bowls: one for the dough, one for the toffee mixture, and one for whipping the cream. Make sure they're sturdy and of varying sizes!

We recommend:
Prime Umite Chef Mixing Bowls with Airtight Lids, 6 piece Stainless Steel Metal Nesting Storage Bowls, Non-Slip Bottoms Size 7, 3.5, 2.5, 2.0,1.5, 1QT, Great for Mixing & Serving (Khaki)
4.6
(27,811) Umite Chef Mixing Bowls with Airtight Lids, 6 piece Stainless Steel Metal Nesting Storage Bowls, Non-Slip Bottoms Size 7, 3.5, 2.5, 2.0,1.5, 1QT, Great for Mixing & Serving (Khaki) $32.28 $37.99 View details
Rolling Pin

A solid rolling pin is essential for evenly rolling out the dough. If it’s your first time, practice with a small piece of dough to get the hang of it.

We recommend:
Prime best seller Farberware Classic Wood Rolling Pin, 17.75-Inch, Natural
4.7
(20,621) Farberware Classic Wood Rolling Pin, 17.75-Inch, Natural $12.99 $13.99 View details Prime Fox Run Polished Marble Rolling Pin with Wooden Cradle, 10-Inch Barrel, White
4.7
(8,146) Fox Run Polished Marble Rolling Pin with Wooden Cradle, 10-Inch Barrel, White $20.88 View details Prime French Rolling Pin (17 Inches) –WoodenRoll Pin for Fondant, Pie Crust, Cookie, Pastry, Dough –Tapered Design & Smooth Construction - Essential Kitchen Utensil
4.7
(11,010) French Rolling Pin (17 Inches) –WoodenRoll Pin for Fondant, Pie Crust, Cookie, Pastry, Dough –Tapered Design & Smooth Construction - Essential Kitchen Utensil $9.99 View details
Pie Tin

This is where the magic happens. A 9-inch pie tin should do the trick. Non-stick is ideal for easy release!

We recommend:
Prime Mora Ceramic Deep Fluted Pie Dish for Baking - 9 inch Porcelain Pie Plate for Apple, Quiche, Pot Pies, Tart, etc. - Modern Farmhouse Style - Vanilla White
4.9
(984) Mora Ceramic Deep Fluted Pie Dish for Baking - 9 inch Porcelain Pie Plate for Apple, Quiche, Pot Pies, Tart, etc. - Modern Farmhouse Style - Vanilla White $25.99 View details Prime MontoPack 9” Aluminum Foil Pie Pans | Round Disposable Containers with Angled Walls for Tart Baking, Storing, Serving & Reheating | Freezer and Oven Safe, Recyclable | 50-Pack of Cake Tins
4.5
(5,972) MontoPack 9” Aluminum Foil Pie Pans | Round Disposable Containers with Angled Walls for Tart Baking, Storing, Serving & Reheating | Freezer and Oven Safe, Recyclable | 50-Pack of Cake Tins $19.99 $22.99 View details Prime ONE MORE 10inch Natural Kraft Bakery Pie Boxes With PVC Windows,Large Cookie box 10x10x2.5inch 12 of Pack (Brown,12)
4.8
(2,938) ONE MORE 10inch Natural Kraft Bakery Pie Boxes With PVC Windows,Large Cookie box 10x10x2.5inch 12 of Pack (Brown,12) $16.99 View details
Whisk and Spatula

A whisk for blending, and a spatula for folding—all without deflating the cream. Gentle motions are key!

We recommend:
Prime OXO Good Grips 11-Inch Balloon Whisk
4.8
(22,752) OXO Good Grips 11-Inch Balloon Whisk $10.93 $11.95 View details Prime best seller Walfos Silicone Whisk,Stainless Steel Wire Whisk Set of 3 -Heat Resistant 480°F Kitchen Whisks for Non-stick Cookware,Balloon Egg Beater Perfect for Blending,Whisking,Beating,Frothing & Stirring,Black
4.7
(9,797) Walfos Silicone Whisk,Stainless Steel Wire Whisk Set of 3 -Heat Resistant 480°F Kitchen Whisks for Non-stick Cookware,Balloon Egg Beater Perfect for Blending,Whisking,Beating,Frothing & Stirring,Black $11.89 $14.99 View details Prime Silicone Spatula Set - 600°F Heat Resistant Rubber Spatulas for Cooking,Baking,Mixing, Silicone Utensil Sets for Nonstick Cookware,BPA-Free,Dishwasher Safe (Multicolor)
4.7
(8,538) Silicone Spatula Set - 600°F Heat Resistant Rubber Spatulas for Cooking,Baking,Mixing, Silicone Utensil Sets for Nonstick Cookware,BPA-Free,Dishwasher Safe (Multicolor) $13.97 View details
Parchment Paper and Pie Weights or Rice

Pre-baking the crust is crucial. Parchment paper and weights ensure your crust stays flat and bakes evenly.

We recommend:
Prime Katbite 16x24 inch Heavy Duty Parchment Paper Sheets, 100Pcs Precut Non-Stick Full Parchment Sheets for Baking, Cooking, Grilling, Frying and Steaming, Full Sheet Baking Pan Liners, Commercial Baking
4.8
(13,822) Katbite 16x24 inch Heavy Duty Parchment Paper Sheets, 100Pcs Precut Non-Stick Full Parchment Sheets for Baking, Cooking, Grilling, Frying and Steaming, Full Sheet Baking Pan Liners, Commercial Baking $18.99 $25.99 View details Prime Katbite 200Pcs 12x16 In Unbleached Parchment Paper for Baking, Precut Parchment Paper Sheets, Heavy Duty Flat Baking Paper, Half Sheet Baking Sheets for Baking Cookies, Cooking, Air Fryer, Oven
4.8
(11,327) Katbite 200Pcs 12x16 In Unbleached Parchment Paper for Baking, Precut Parchment Paper Sheets, Heavy Duty Flat Baking Paper, Half Sheet Baking Sheets for Baking Cookies, Cooking, Air Fryer, Oven $16.99 $19.99 View details Prime 200 Pcs Unbleached Parchment Paper Baking Sheets, 12 x 16 Inch, Precut Non-Stick Parchment Sheets for Baking, Cooking, Grilling, Air Fryer and Steaming - Unbleached, Fit for Half Sheet Pans
4.8
(13,786) 200 Pcs Unbleached Parchment Paper Baking Sheets, 12 x 16 Inch, Precut Non-Stick Parchment Sheets for Baking, Cooking, Grilling, Air Fryer and Steaming - Unbleached, Fit for Half Sheet Pans $15.99 $19.99 View details

Variations

If you're catering to specific dietary needs, this recipe is versatile enough to accommodate:

🌾 Gluten-Free Option: Use a gluten-free flour blend instead of regular flour for the crust. Ensure all other ingredients are certified gluten-free. Bake as usual and enjoy without the worry!

🌱 Vegan Version: Substitute butter with vegan butter or coconut oil for the crust. Use plant-based cream cheese and heavy cream alternatives (like coconut cream or a cashew blend). Replace egg yolks with a mixture of flaxseed and water for binding. Your vegan caramel dream awaits! 😋

Faq

  • Should I blind bake the crust?

    Absolutely! Blind baking ensures the crust is fully cooked and won’t get soggy when you add the filling.

  • Why did my filling turn out runny?

    The filling sets as it cools. Patience is key! Ensure it cools completely before serving.

  • Can I make the crust in advance?

    Yes, you can prepare the crust and store it in the fridge wrapped in plastic wrap for up to 2 days or freeze it for up to a month.

  • Can I use store-bought toffees?

    Yes, just make sure to melt them down properly with the milk to get a smooth mixture.

  • How do I prevent the dough from sticking when rolling out?

    Lightly flour the surface and your rolling pin. If it still sticks, place the dough between two sheets of parchment paper.

  • Is there a specific type of cream cheese I should use?

    Full-fat cream cheese works best for a rich, creamy texture. Make sure it’s at room temperature before whipping.

Nutrition facts

Undertale Toffee Pie
Recipe Yield:8 servings
Calories:Approximately 375 calories per serving
Calories (Min - Max):350 - 400
Total Fat:29g
Saturated Fat:18g
Protein:6g
Total Carbohydrate:25g
Total Sugars:12g